Is Alcoholics Anonymous More Effective Than Cognitve Behavioral Therapy?

Question by abnjim5: Is Alcoholics Anonymous more effective than Cognitve Behavioral Therapy?
Much debate exists about which model is more effective in treating the problem of drug addiction. Some say AA is the only treatment that “works” while others choose the more human friendly non-religious CBT. AA uses rigid spiritual concepts based on their 12 steps and conducts their AA meetings on strict formats that were written seven decades ago. In AA “labels” like alcoholic are used which still holds a high degree of social stigmatism. Cognitive Behaviour programs like SMART (self-management and rehab treatment) sees substance abuse as a behaviour that can be changed, not a disease. CBT self-help methods are solidly based in comtemporary science and open discussions are encouraged. AA tells it members and “newcomers” that they need to find a higher power or god and relying on “self will” is bad and will lead to relapse.

If you were having problems with drugs, which would you choose for help, AA or CBT?

Best answer:

Answer by synchronicity915
I think it depends on the person.

Know better? Leave your own answer in the comments!

Drug and Alcohol Rehab – Residential Inpatient – Florida Rehab – Here at www.oceanbreezerecovery.org we provide the highest level of addiction treatment care for drug addiction and alcoholism. Our effective Florida drug rehab programs include individualized proven addiction treatment modalities to help you or your loved one recover. Ocean Breeze Recovery – 855-627-7700 Why did you start Ocean Breeze Recovery? I started Ocean Breeze because I felt like something was burning inside of me to help the addict and alcoholic. I just felt compelled to try to touch some peoples lives the way they were touched for me and I wanted to do it in a unique and special way. Do you feel as though you have touched a lot of lives? Without a doubt. If we touch one it was all worth it and we’ve done way more than that. I think the record speaks for itself the way our clients have stayed sober after they’ve left. We have a number of clients who are doing phenomenal in life and that just warms my heart. When you started Ocean Breeze, what were your goals? What did you feel was missing in other treatment centers? I think the main componenent with what was missing was love and compassion. I’m trying to let them see that I understand where they’re coming from and what they’re feeling and most importantly what they can do moving forward. I just want to pass on what was given to me. I wanted to broaden their horizons and help them dream big again. They come in hopeless and they leave they have that little glimmer and that little glimmer is all you need to start …